10 Best Soft Plastic Baits for Walleye this year

Soft plastic walleye baits arranged in an open tackle box on a boat deck

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links – if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

There’s no single best soft plastic bait for walleye. The right one depends on three things: how you fish (casting, jigging, or trolling), what the fish are eating in your water, and how much action you want the bait to do on its own. Two picks split most walleye anglers: the Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow for a scented, do-it-all bait, and the Northland Eye Candy Leech if you want a bait that floats and lasts.

1Best Overall
Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow
Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow
2Most Proven Worm
Berkley PowerBait Power Worms
Berkley PowerBait Power Worms
3Best Nightcrawler Profile
Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler
Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler
4Best Walleye-Specific
Northland Eye Candy Leech
Northland Eye Candy Leech
5Best Grub Action
Berkley PowerBait Power Grubs
Berkley PowerBait Power Grubs
6Best Ripple Tail
Berkley PowerBait Ripple Shad
Berkley PowerBait Ripple Shad
7Best Paddle Tail
Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad
Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad
8Best Finesse Minnow
Berkley PowerBait Power Minnow
Berkley PowerBait Power Minnow
9Best Pre-Rigged Swimbait
TRUSCEND Shadtale
TRUSCEND Shadtale
10Best Kicking Action
Rapala CrushCity Mayor
Rapala CrushCity Mayor

1. Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow Fishing Soft Bait

Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers who want one scented bait for many species.

If walleye mix with perch, crappie, and panfish, you want a bait that draws fish from a distance. That’s the idea behind this one. It comes soaked in a powerful attractant the listing says expands your strike zone. When the scent wears off, you put it back in the jar to recharge.

At 1 inch in Blue Shiner, it’s a small profile that matches small forage.

Good if:

  • You fish mixed species and want a single bait that covers all of them
  • You like the idea of a bait you can recharge instead of replacing
  • You want a small, forage-matching profile

Skip it if:

  • You only chase trophy walleye on large baitfish

2. Berkley PowerBait Power Worms Fishing Soft Bait

Berkley PowerBait Power Worms

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers who fish a classic worm and want more hookups.

This is the ribbon-tail worm that’s been in tackle boxes for decades. According to the listing, it increases bite retention by 18x, giving you time to set more hooks.

That matters because walleye often grab and let go. You can rig it Texas style, Carolina style, or on a dragging jighead like a shaky head. It comes in four sizes and multiple colorways.

Good if:

  • You already fish worms and want better hook retention
  • You want a bait you can rig several different ways
  • You fish spring through fall and want a year-round profile

Skip it if:

  • Your water has walleye feeding hard on baitfish

3. Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler Natural

Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler

Check Latest Price on Amazon

You May Like  Best Fishing Pole Holder for Jet Ski: Top Durable and Versatile Picks

Best for: Trollers pulling spinner rigs for walleye.

If you troll, you want a bait that looks, feels, and smells like a live nightcrawler without the mess. That’s exactly what this listing promises. It’s built for trolling on spinner rigs and carries an exclusive walleye PowerBait scent and flavor formula. The 6-inch size and 13-count pack give you a full day of trolling without constant rebaiting.

Good if:

  • You troll spinner rigs for walleye
  • You want live-worm looks without live-worm care
  • You want a walleye-specific scent formula

Skip it if:

  • You mostly cast and jig from shore or a boat

4. Northland Tackle Eye Candy Riggin Leech Floating 4.25″ Soft Plastic

Northland Eye Candy Leech

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Walleye anglers who want a floating, durable leech.

This one is built specifically for walleye. The Super TPE material lasts fish after fish.

The body is an ultra-thin leech design that displaces water and keeps moving. One note from the listing itself: keep it in the original packaging and don’t mix it with other soft plastics.

Good if:

  • You want a bait that floats and stays off the bottom
  • You fish jigs, spinner rigs, or harnesses for walleye
  • You want a leech profile that survives fish after fish

Skip it if:

  • You mix all your plastics loose in a single tray

5. Berkley PowerBait Power Grubs Fishing Soft Bait

Berkley PowerBait Power Grubs

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers who fish slow and want action at any speed.

A grub is the simplest soft bait there is, and this one has a bulky body for easier rigging. The listing says it delivers best-in-class action even at the slowest speeds. A bait that keeps moving when you barely turn the reel handle gets attention when nothing else does.

It comes in a 4-inch White and multiple colorways and sizes, and targets bass, walleye, trout, and panfish.

Good if:

  • You fish slow and want action at low speed
  • You want a bulky body that’s easy to rig
  • You fish several species and want a single grub for all of them

Skip it if:

  • You only fish fast, aggressive presentations

6. Berkley PowerBait Ripple Shad Fishing Soft Bait

Berkley PowerBait Ripple Shad

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers covering water with a vibrating swimbait.

When you’re searching for fish, you want a bait that sends out vibration and covers water. This one has a segmented body that creates more vibration and swimming action. The HD Tru Colors and 3D red eyes mimic natural prey, which helps on cautious fish.

It comes in a 3 1/2-inch Fire Perch and multiple swimbait sizes. The listing says it works on a jig head, weighted swimbait hook, or drop shot, and targets walleye, pike, and crappie.

Good if:

  • You want to cover water and find active fish
  • You fish clear water where realistic color matters
  • You want a bait that works for walleye and pike

Skip it if:

  • You fish a slow, bottom-hugging presentation

7. Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad Fishing Soft Bait

Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad

Check Latest Price on Amazon

You May Like  Best Wacky Rig Silicone Bands for Fishing 2026: Top Picks to Buy

Best for: Walleye anglers who want a pro-selected paddle tail.

This paddle tail has a lifelike baitfish profile with an optimized nose for jig heads. The colors were selected by two top walleye pros, so the palette was built around walleye water.

It’s made from the Gulp! Material for extreme scent dispersion, and the listing says it’s ideally rigged on a weighted EWG swimbait hook or a jig head.

Good if:

  • You want a paddle tail built for walleye water
  • You like rigging your own jig heads and swimbait hooks
  • You want a bait with strong scent dispersion

Skip it if:

  • You want a pre-rigged bait ready out of the pack
  • You fish a bait that needs a curl tail instead of a paddle

8. Berkley PowerBait Power Minnow Fishing Bait

Berkley PowerBait Power Minnow

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Finesse anglers fishing clear water and pressured fish.

Sometimes walleye want something small and subtle. This minnow has a split tail design that mimics forage fish. At 2 inches in Black Shad, it’s a compact bait with 3D eyes and holographic inserts. The listing notes it’s pre-rigged, so it’s ready to fish straight from the pack.

Good if:

  • You fish clear, pressured water where subtle wins
  • You want a pre-rigged bait ready to fish
  • You want a small baitfish profile

Skip it if:

9. TRUSCEND Shadtale Easy Catch Soft Fishing Lures with BKK Hooks

TRUSCEND Shadtale

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers who want a pre-rigged bait with premium hooks.

This is the ready-to-fish option. It comes with sharp, corrosion-resistant BKK hooks already attached, so no hook upgrade is needed. A steady retrieve gives a tight vibrating swim with paddle tail kick, and jigging hops create a trembling fall.

Good if:

  • You want a bait that’s ready to fish out of the pack
  • You want premium hooks without upgrading
  • You fish both steady retrieves and jigging hops

Skip it if:

  • You want to rig your own hooks and weights
  • You want to change the hook size for different fish

10. Rapala CrushCity Mayor Soft Plastic Paddle Tail Swimbait

Rapala CrushCity Mayor

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Best for: Anglers who want a consistent tail kick at any speed.

The Mayor is a paddle tail swimbait with a natural baitfish profile that mimics shad and minnows. The listing says the tail kicks and the body rolls consistently at slow to fast speeds. That consistency is what you want when you’re not sure how the fish want it — you can change speed without losing the action. It works on jig heads, underspins, swim jigs, and weighted hooks.

Good if:

  • You want consistent action across retrieve speeds
  • You fish underspins, swim jigs, or weighted hooks
  • You chase pressured fish in clear water

Skip it if:

  • You need a bait for a dead-slow bottom presentation

Where Soft Plastic Baits for Walleye Overlap

Several of these are close enough that the choice barely matters. The Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad and the Rapala CrushCity Mayor are both paddle tail swimbaits for the same job — pick the Gulp! If you want scent dispersion, and the Mayor if you want consistent action across speeds. The PowerBait Power Grubs and the Ripple Shad overlap too, since both are moving baits with PowerBait scent. What genuinely separates the list is profile: the leech, nightcrawler, and worm are natural shapes, while the minnows and shads are baitfish shapes.

You May Like  10 Best Bass Lures for Night Fishing | Top Glow and Topwater Picks

Still Not Sure?

How often will I actually fish this bait?

Be honest about your season. If you fish walleye a few weekends a year, the Berkley PowerBait Power Worms covers the most ground with one pack. If you’re on the water weekly and troll, the Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler earns its place.

What do I already own that this has to work with?

Check your jig heads, spinner rigs, and hooks before you buy. The Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad and Rapala CrushCity Mayor need jig heads or swimbait hooks you rig yourself. The TRUSCEND Shadtale and PowerBait Power Minnow come ready to fish.

What am I most likely to regret choosing?

Most anglers regret buying a bait that doesn’t match their water. If your lake is murky, the Northland Eye Candy Leech floats and moves where fish can find it. If it’s clear and pressured, the Berkley PowerBait Ripple Shad and its realistic colors are the safer bet.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size soft plastic bait is best for walleye?

It depends on the forage. Small profiles like the 1-inch Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow and 2-inch PowerBait Power Minnow match small baitfish. Bigger baits like the 6-inch PowerBait Power Nightcrawler and 4.25-inch Northland Eye Candy Leech match larger forage and trolling presentations.

Do I need a scented soft plastic for walleye?

It helps when fish grab and let go. Berkley’s PowerBait formula is used across the Power Worms, Power Grubs, Ripple Shad, and Power Minnow, with the listing claiming fish hold on 18 times longer. The Gulp! Baits use a separate material for scent dispersion.

Can I use these soft plastics for trolling?

Yes, some are built for it. The Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler is designed for trolling on spinner rigs, and the Northland Eye Candy Leech works on spinner rigs and harnesses. Both are shaped to trail naturally behind a moving presentation.

What’s the difference between a paddle tail and a curl tail for walleye?

A paddle tail like the Berkley Gulp! Paddleshad or Rapala CrushCity Mayor gives a tight vibrating swim for covering water. A curl or ribbon tail like the PowerBait Power Worms gives a slower, rolling action for dragging rigs. Match the tail to how fast you plan to fish.

Conclusion

If you want one scented bait that covers many species, the Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow is your pick. If you want a floating leech built for walleye and nothing else, go with the Northland Eye Candy Leech. Check the listing on Amazon and pick the profile that matches your water.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *